Newmarket mayor disappointed as province puts brakes on Upper York Sewage Solutions plant

The province is going against its promise to be 'open for business' by creating a panel that will further delay the solution needed to accommodate future growth in Newmarket, Aurora and East Gwillimbury

Newmarkettoday.ca
June 4, 2021
Joseph Quigley

Mayor John Taylor said it is "unacceptable" that the province is halting the environmental assessment for the proposed Upper Sewage Solutions plant that is key to future growth in Newmarket.

Minister of Environment, Conservation and Parks Jeff Yurek introduced Bill 306: York Region Wastewater Act today, June 3, at Queen's Park, stating that the minister will not make any decision regarding the assessment, which was originally submitted in 2014 but has remained unapproved by successive governments.

Yurek said the province will instead establish an expert panel to review sewage solutions in the region.

Taylor told NewmarketToday that he is "extremely disappointed" by the lack of a decision.

"We're in government to make tough choices," Taylor said. "Making no decisions is not, in my opinion, responsible."

The Upper York Sewage Solutions $715-million plant at East Gwillimbury has been stalled for years. It has generated concern over the possible impact on the Lake Simcoe watershed, with the Town of Georgina and Chippewas of Georgina Island First Nation opposing it. The plant would treat East Gwillimbury, Newmarket and Aurora sewage.

The province has previously proposed an alternative that would send wastewater to an existing plant in Pickering. York Region signalled in January that it would continue pushing for the East Gwillimbury plant, but that it would remain open to the provincial alternative.

Yurek said the government wants to ensure it has up-to-date information and consider options.

“Many years have passed since this environmental assessment began,” Yurek said in the Ontario Legislature. “This government wants to ensure that we have the most up-to-date information on the environmental, social and financial impacts of alternatives to provide wastewater services appropriately.”

The proposed East Gwillimbury plant would address sewage capacity issues for Newmarket, which is due to reach its maximum limit within 10 years. Taylor said more capacity is vital to allow the municipality to grow and create more housing.

"We will soon be without capacity to build one more home,” Taylor said. “Constrained supply for another year or two is only going to drive prices up and make things less affordable."

He said he is concerned about how long an expert panel might take to present its findings. If the province wants to go with the alternative option, they should compel York Region to proceed that way, he added.

Yurek said the panel would include a variety of experts.

“A variety of areas, including land use planning, wastewater infrastructure, and ... key stakeholders like our Indigenous communities that will be affected,” Yurek said.

Taylor said the panel is "red tape" and goes against the provincial government's promises to be "open for business."

"It is not moving the region forward or the province forward," he said.